Used 2023 GMC Sierra HD: What to look for before buying
Owners have filed 62 complaints with NHTSA about this car, most about the transmission, electrical, and wheels and tires. The 9 checks below target those problems, in the order you would do them at the car.
NHTSA data through October 2026Updated Maintained by Arnas Kazlaus
2023- Owner complaints
- 62
- Recalls
- 1
- Crashes reported
- 6
- 2 injuries
- Reliability
- Good
- 73/100 on Auto Reliability Index
Your inspection sheet
Tick items off on your phone at the car, or print it. Ticks stay on this device.
0/9 checked
2023 GMC Sierra HD: inspection sheet
Paperwork and questions
Before you go, or before you touch the car0/2
Walk-around and cabin
Engine off, key in hand0/1
Cold start, engine bay, and underside
Ask the seller not to warm the car up first0/2
Test drive
At least 20 minutes, with some highway0/4
These checks are specific to this model year. For tires, body panels, fluids, and the other basics every used car needs, use the general inspection guide.
Check the odometer against these mileages
Owners report these failures starting around the mileages below. A car inside one of these ranges deserves a closer look at that part, or records showing it was already fixed.
Factory tire tread separation
14,500–32,000 miles
Transmission valve body failure
15,000–36,000 miles
Why these checks: what owners reported
NHTSA complaints for the 2023 GMC Sierra HD, grouped by the part owners named. Open a row to read what goes wrong.
Transmission302 crashes
The transmission valve body fails on the 10-speed Allison. The truck makes a hard shift or jerk, then drops into limp mode with reduced engine power and a check engine light, often with codes P0700 and P0747. Some trucks stay stuck in a low gear and top out near 40 to 55 mph. Others lock the rear wheels at highway speed, and there are 2 crash-related reports and 1 injury. Failures usually come between 15,000 and 36,000 miles, sometimes more than once. Backordered parts keep trucks at dealers for weeks or months.
Electrical8No crashes
Towing electrics cause the most trouble. Trailer brake warnings come on, trailers show as unconnected, lights blink or quit, and the brake controller can cut trailer brakes on a downhill grade while the screen still says all is well. Plastic on the rear sliding window melts after the defroster is used. Other reports describe a key that won't come out in Park, repeated no-starts after sitting even with new batteries, and a failed transmission control module waiting on parts. Many owners say dealers still can't fix the problem after several visits.
Wheels and tires71 crash
Factory Goodyear Wrangler 275/65R20 tires lose their tread at highway speed. The tread peels off or the tire bursts, sometimes while towing, and flying tread damages the bumper, tailgate, wheel well, and nearby vehicles. One owner noticed a bad vibration before the tire let go. Failures fall roughly between 14,500 and 32,000 miles. Smaller complaints cover a trailer tire pressure sensor that loses signal because of its range and mounting spot, and tread that picks up rocks and throws them at the truck's steps.
The reports filed here describe problems found elsewhere on the truck. One is the transmission valve body failure: the truck shudders, loses power, won't go into Park or Drive, and gets towed for a full transmission replacement. This complaint is marked crash-related. The other is a factory Goodyear Wrangler tire that lost its tread at highway speed at about 14,500 miles with correct pressure and no warning. The loose tread tore up the bedside, bumper, taillight, and trim.
Engine31 crash
Most of these reports describe the transmission valve body failure, not an engine fault. The truck shudders, loses power, shows reduced power warnings, and cannot go past about 50 mph. In one case the wheels locked up and the truck would not shift out of drive, which led to a crash. Another truck shut off completely in the middle of a highway. One failure came at 22,000 miles, and that truck sat at the dealer for 9 weeks because no replacement valve body could be found.
Brakes3No crashes
Brake hardware fails early in a few trucks. In one, the parking brake shoe lining came loose from the shoe at 26,000 miles. In another, brake fluid leaks from a seal at the driver side brake assembly, a repair covered by warranty. A third report is really the transmission failure. While towing downhill, the transmission shut down, the exhaust brake turned off, and the truck went into reduced power mode and had to be towed.
Automatic emergency braking21 crash
The driver aids don't always do what buyers expect. One crash report describes the tailgate flying open on its own and dumping cargo. As the driver pulled over, lane departure steering tried to correct the truck and it hit the median. Another buyer was told the truck had adaptive cruise control and lane keep assist, then found days after buying it that neither feature worked. An electrical complaint describes the same missing adaptive cruise.
In owners' own words
Excerpts from complaints Sierra HD owners filed with NHTSA, as written. Listen for the same symptoms on your test drive.
This issue is pertaining to the valve body in my 10-speed transmission. While I was traveling home, the truck experienced a “wheel lockup”. The transmission shifted down aggressively, then putting the truck into limp mode. I had to travel the rest of the way home with a max speed of 35 mph. I have been without this truck for 3 months waiting on parts. This is absolutely unacceptable from gm. Extremely unsave.
Filed with NHTSA, July 2025
Bought a 2023 gmc sierra 2500 duramax. Went into limp mode took it to dealership the transmission was bad so they replace transmission after 3 month of dealer having my truck . Got the truck back still having issues with transmission not shifting right and the rear tires locking up at highway speeds .
Filed with NHTSA, September 2025
When vehicle is shifted into Park you are not able to remove the key. I have taken the vehicle to 5 different dealers, and no one can fix the problem. Many forums show the exact same problem - something in the steering column is defective. Began happening in 2023 with only 12,000 miles on the vehicle.
Filed with NHTSA, November 2026
There are 2 issues with this vehicle: #1) The rear window defrost causes an electrical issue that melted the plastic on our rear sliding window. Dealer claims we put something hot against the window but we did not. This appeared after we used the rear defrost. Several other owners have complained about this as well. #2) The vehicle is advertised as having adaptive cruise but it does not have this feature.
Filed with NHTSA, August 2024
Complete Tread/belt separation originating inside the tire. I have the complete tire and the complete tread. This happened at highway speed. I'm going to the dealer to get an inspection. The only symptom was a bad vibration before the tread separation. LT275/65R20E
Filed with NHTSA, September 2026
I was driving in the high way and the vehicle started having issues and then it completely shut off and wouldn’t drive or anything in the middle of the highway and the dash said it was reducing power.
Filed with NHTSA, January 2026
How the 2023 compares with other Sierra HD years
Complaints for this year next to the average for the other model years, area by area.
The 2023 ranks fifth for owner complaints among 9 Sierra HD years, close to the average of the others. Newer years have had less time to collect complaints, so compare like with like.
- Transmission3014
- Electrical812
- Wheels and tires74
- Engine37
- Brakes39
- Automatic emergency braking20
Where the 2023 fits in the Sierra HD's history
Redesigns and mid-cycle updates change what can go wrong.
The 2023 is the fourth model year of the Sierra HD's fourth generation (2020 on).
GMC updated the Sierra HD for 2024, so a 2023 does not have those changes.
What changed for 2024 (not on a 2023)
- Updated interior and front styling
- More powerful Duramax diesel
Recalls to confirm (1)
Recall repairs are free at any GMC dealer, but the seller may never have had them done. Check each campaign number against the VIN before you buy.
- 24V060000Door latches and locksJan 2024
Open a campaign number for NHTSA's full notice: what fails, the risk, and the fix.
Also looking at these instead of a Sierra HD?
Cars shoppers compare with the GMC Sierra HD, with their own 2023 checklists.
2023 owner complaints, side by side
- 2023 GMC Sierra HD62
- Chevrolet Silverado HD64
- Ram Heavy Duty68
- Ford Super Duty92


