Used 2021 GMC Sierra HD: What to look for before buying
Owners have filed 74 complaints with NHTSA about this car, most about the transmission, brakes, and electrical. The 10 checks below target those problems, in the order you would do them at the car.
NHTSA data through October 2026Updated Maintained by Arnas Kazlaus
2021- Owner complaints
- 74
- Recalls
- 6
- 1 urgent
- Crashes reported
- 4
- 1 injury
- Reliability
- Good
- 66/100 on Auto Reliability Index
One recall on this model year told owners to park outside until the repair was done.
Do not buy until you have dealer paperwork or a recall lookup showing it was completed for this VIN.
Your inspection sheet
Tick items off on your phone at the car, or print it. Ticks stay on this device.
0/10 checked
2021 GMC Sierra HD: inspection sheet
Paperwork and questions
Before you go, or before you touch the car0/3
Walk-around and cabin
Engine off, key in hand0/2
Cold start, engine bay, and underside
Ask the seller not to warm the car up first0/2
Test drive
At least 20 minutes, with some highway0/3
These checks are specific to this model year. For tires, body panels, fluids, and the other basics every used car needs, use the general inspection guide.
Check the odometer against these mileages
Owners report these failures starting around the mileages below. A car inside one of these ranges deserves a closer look at that part, or records showing it was already fixed.
Headlamp water intrusion and failure
29,000–40,000 miles
Transmission failure and replacement
47,000–82,000 miles
Why these checks: what owners reported
NHTSA complaints for the 2021 GMC Sierra HD, grouped by the part owners named. Open a row to read what goes wrong.
Transmission181 crash
Sudden transmission failure dominates these reports. Trucks downshift on their own at highway speed, often while towing, and slow abruptly. In one case that pushed a truck off the road into a post and injured the driver. Other symptoms are hard shifting, lurching, surging, revving with no power, a "Vehicle will not Exceed 50 MPH" message, rear wheels locking up, and acting as if in neutral when pulling into traffic. Failures cluster between about 47,000 and 82,000 miles and usually end in a full transmission replacement. Several trucks sat at dealers for weeks or months waiting on parts.
Brakes10No crashes
Pedals go soft and sink toward the floor in some trucks, and at least one would not stop until the driver pumped the brakes. Pads squeal and keep squealing after pad and caliper replacements, starting as early as 800 miles. The electronic parking brake shows service warnings, locks up, or stops working when the rear parking brake shoes come apart. Other reports describe brake fluid dripping onto the driver's floor mat, a trailer brake connection that cuts out on steep grades, and a front brake grabbing hard enough to pull the truck toward oncoming traffic.
Electrical81 crash
Backup cameras shut off in reverse. In one report that led to a crash into the wall of a house. A green smear can also spread across the camera view until it hides the image. The instrument cluster sometimes goes dark and reboots while driving. Other reports include water getting into the trailer lighting plug and shorting it, condensation inside the headlamp assemblies, a key fob that locks and unlocks the truck from a pocket, and plastic melting near the rear sliding window while the rear defroster runs.
Engine8No crashes
False diesel exhaust fluid warnings are the most common thread. The dash shows a low-DEF countdown to reduced speed even when the tank is full, and one truck's DEF tank was replaced twice. A failed DEF heater can hold a truck to 55 mph, with the part on back order. A few trucks suffer complete engine failure around 77,000 to 80,000 miles, including stalls at speed with no warning lights, and one stalled again after its engine was replaced. Single reports cite a throttle that sticks open and an engine block heater that trips a household outlet.
Exterior lights8No crashes
Water gets inside the headlamp assemblies and shorts the lighting electronics. Daytime running lights flicker, high beams flash on their own, and turn signals fail. Eventually the headlight quits completely, and some trucks lose the second side months later. Many failures show up just past the 36,000-mile warranty, so owners pay for repairs themselves. The fix is a full assembly replacement, with quotes running from $1,400 for one part to $3,700 for both sides. Losing forward lighting at night is the main safety risk, and some trucks become undrivable until the repair is done.
Body and structure4No crashes
The tailgate falls open while the truck is moving. One owner lost cargo on the road twice without noticing until arriving home. Any loose load in the bed can spill onto the road behind the truck. Single reports describe the center hood scoop blowing off while driving and a power side step that fails to extend, the second at 93,726 miles. Only a few reports exist, but the tailgate problem also shows up under latches and locks.
Door latches and locks4No crashes
The power tailgate unlatches and opens by itself, both at 25 to 35 mph and while parked, and a tailgate-open message usually follows. Most of these reports involve a recall repair to the tailgate touchpad switch that owners say went wrong. They describe parts that were not yet available, a repair marked complete that a second dealer said was never done, and tailgates that opened again after only one of the switches was replaced. One owner also reports flashing lights and a clicking actuator after the repair.
Wheels and tires3No crashes
Tread separates on the original tires, sometimes with a loud boom or a highway blowout that makes the truck hard to control. The flying tread damaged quarter panels, bumpers, and fenders, and one truck had a second tire showing early separation. Two reports name Goodyear Wrangler tires in the 275/65R20 size. A third describes an aftermarket tire coming apart within a year. No injuries are reported, but a separation at highway speed is a loss-of-control risk.
In owners' own words
Excerpts from complaints Sierra HD owners filed with NHTSA, as written. Listen for the same symptoms on your test drive.
The owns a 2021 GMC Sierra 2500. The contact stated while driving 70 MPH, the RPM revved up to 6,000 RPM. Additionally, the vehicle lost motive power. The vehicle was taken to the dealer, who informed the contact that the transmission needed to be replaced. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was not made aware of the failure. The failure mileage was 47,000. The VIN was not available.
Filed with NHTSA, June 2023
We keep getting an error message that shows we need to service DEF SYSTEM, it also started to limit my MPH and is now locked at 55 MPH. initial check of the DEF SYSTEM shows a malfunctioning module. it has been happening over the last year to 18 months. they would reset it or it would sometimes go away on its own after having to drive it in order for the error to clear.
Filed with NHTSA, May 2026
Seems to be a known problem according to a google search but brake fluid leaking from brake pedal onto drivers floor mat. Seems to be a bad brake booster according to google and happening for some at a few weeks to a couple months old in the newer ones. I noticed first on my truck around 58,000 miles.
Filed with NHTSA, December 2024
Trailer brake wiring connection continually disconnectsthen reconnects some time later. Some periods of up to 10 minutes without having trailer braking power. Major safety issue when toeing fifth wheel trailer. We lost brakes going down steep grades. GMC is aware of issue, but has not provided a solution. Vehicle has been yo service shop with no resolution. Case has been opened with GMC.
Filed with NHTSA, June 2021
When I’m in reverse the up the cameras turn off. On one incident I was backing up and the camera turned off causing me to back up into the wall of my house
Filed with NHTSA, September 2025
The harness that hooks to bumper plug for trailer lighting is not completely water tight. Allows water in and creates buildup that weakens the connection as well as allows the plug wire connection to snap out and push out from the pin. Further inspection it was causing a short in the system. I attempted to clean and put some-electric grease on the plug to help clean it but then relaized 3 pins were broken and pushed back.
Filed with NHTSA, March 2024
•The diesel exhaust fluid heater is a faulty component in the system, there is a back order on the part with no ETA • My pickup only does 55MPH right now and soon to do 5MPH you cannot drive on a public road doing 5MPH •There is thousands of other people having the same exact problem! •The DEF light is illuminated on my dash along with the check engine light, when you diagnose the error code it comes up with “P20C1 Reductant Heater C Control Circuit/OPEN”
Filed with NHTSA, February 2022
How the 2021 compares with other Sierra HD years
Complaints for this year next to the average for the other model years, area by area.
The 2021 ranks fourth for owner complaints among 9 Sierra HD years, close to the average of the others. Newer years have had less time to collect complaints, so compare like with like.
- Transmission1815
- Brakes109
- Electrical812
- Engine86
- Exterior lights82
- Body and structure43
Where the 2021 fits in the Sierra HD's history
Redesigns and mid-cycle updates change what can go wrong.
The 2021 is the second model year of the Sierra HD's fourth generation (2020 on).
GMC updated the Sierra HD for 2024, so a 2021 does not have those changes.
What changed for 2024 (not on a 2021)
- Updated interior and front styling
- More powerful Duramax diesel
Recalls to confirm (6)
Recall repairs are free at any GMC dealer, but the seller may never have had them done. Check each campaign number against the VIN before you buy.
- 21V758000BrakesPark outside
- 24V060000Door latches and locksJan 2024
- 20V792000Seat belts
- 20V811000Seat belts
- 21V578000Wheels and tires
- 24V797000Transmission
Open a campaign number for NHTSA's full notice: what fails, the risk, and the fix.
Also looking at these instead of a Sierra HD?
Cars shoppers compare with the GMC Sierra HD, with their own 2021 checklists.
2021 owner complaints, side by side
- 2021 GMC Sierra HD74
- Chevrolet Silverado HD130
- Ram Heavy Duty172
- Ford Super Duty287


