Used Car Checklists

Used 2024 BMW i5: What to look for before buying

Owners have filed 22 complaints with NHTSA about this car, most about the electrical, stability control, and brakes. The 9 checks below target those problems, in the order you would do them at the car.

NHTSA data through October 2026Updated Maintained by Arnas Kazlaus

BMW i52024
Owner complaints
22
Recalls
10
Crashes reported
2
Reliability
Good
63/100 on Auto Reliability Index

Run the VIN before you go

A history report shows accidents, title brands, odometer readings, and open recalls for this 2024 BMW i5. Ask the seller for the VIN; it is also on the dash at the base of the windshield.

Your inspection sheet

Tick items off on your phone at the car, or print it. Ticks stay on this device.

These checks are specific to this model year. For tires, body panels, fluids, and the other basics every used car needs, use the general inspection guide.

Reported on other i5 years with the same design

These years share the 2024's design and most of its parts, so their problems are the ones to look for on this car too.

2025 i5

8 owner complaints
  • Brakes 3
  • Transmission 2

Worth adding to your 2024 checks

  • Hold the brake firmly at a stop and confirm the car stays still without creeping or surging forward.
  • Brake firmly during slow turns and U-turns and check that the pedal stays firm and does not sink.
  • Check the dash and service history for "Drivetrain malfunction" or powertrain warnings and any repeat repairs.
Open the 2025 checklist

Which i5 is it?

EPA figures for each version of the 2024 BMW i5. Use them to confirm you are looking at the version that was advertised, and as a yardstick on the test drive.

VersionDriveEPA rating
Electric4WD, RWD256–295 mi range
  • With a full charge, the range estimate on the dash should land near the EPA figure of 256–295 miles. A much lower number on a mild day can mean a worn battery; ask for a battery health report.

Why these checks: what owners reported

NHTSA complaints for the 2024 BMW i5, grouped by the part owners named. Open a row to read what goes wrong.

  • Electrical5No crashes

    The most common complaint is loud fan noise, clunking and banging during and after DC fast charging, sometimes with a battery temperature warning. Dealer notes link the clicking to a coolant water valve under the hood. Owners say the valve shares a cooling loop with the high-voltage battery and that no fix exists yet. Other reports describe the car failing to charge fully from a low battery, with arcing found on the charging pins. One report describes power steering failing suddenly at about 21,344 miles, along with stability control, parking brake hold and parking assist, which left the car free to roll.

  • Stability control41 crash

    Most of these reports are about a recall repair that cannot be done because the part is unavailable. Owners say the wait has gone past a reasonable time, and several have had no failure so far. One crash report describes the car accelerating while parking with the brake pressed and hitting a wall. That car was declared a total loss, and no injuries were reported. A separate report describes a driver restraint system malfunction message at startup at about 9,000 miles.

  • Brakes3No crashes

    A warning that braking may require additional force can appear suddenly while driving, including while merging into highway traffic, with no earlier symptoms. This undermines confidence in stopping at speed. The other reports center on a pending recall repair. Owners say the remedy part is unavailable, dealers cannot give a timeline, and the manufacturer has shared little about the crash risk or when parts will arrive.

  • Backup camera2No crashes

    While reversing, the central display can black out for 3 to 5 seconds, wiping out the rear camera image without warning and forcing hard braking near people or objects. A dealer replaced the head unit in response. In other reports, the rear cross traffic and blind spot warnings make no audible alert. Owners say this makes it easy to back into traffic that appears quickly, such as cars coming over a hill crest.

  • Transmission2No crashes

    Drive power can cut out completely. Reports describe a red shutdown warning followed by full loss of propulsion in slow traffic, and the car shifting itself into neutral at highway speed with a drivetrain error. Steering and brakes may keep working, but the car can only coast to the roadside. Power comes back after a restart or after shifting to Park and then back to Drive. Owners also describe jerking, shuddering and surging that gets more frequent over time.

In owners' own words

Excerpts from complaints i5 owners filed with NHTSA, as written. Listen for the same symptoms on your test drive.

Backup camera
Rear Cross Traffic Warning does not produce an audible alert. It can cause you to accidentally back into oncoming traffic. This has been the case on several occasions especially when there is a hill behind you and traffic crests the hill and appears quickly. Blind Spot Warning does not produce an audible alert or view in the instrument cluster.

Filed with NHTSA, June 2024

How the 2024 compares with other i5 years

Complaints for this year next to the average for the other model years, area by area.

The 2024 has the most owner complaints of the 2 i5 years we cover, about 2.8 times the average of the others. Newer years have had less time to collect complaints, so compare like with like.

2024 Average of other years
  • Electrical50
  • Stability control40
  • Brakes33
  • Backup camera20
  • Transmission22

Where the 2024 fits in the i5's history

Redesigns and mid-cycle updates change what can go wrong.

The 2024 is the first model year of the i5's eighth generation (2024 on). First years of a redesign often carry teething problems that BMW fixes in later years, so the checks above matter more than usual.

Should you avoid the first year of a redesign? See the 45-car study.

Recalls to confirm (10)

Recall repairs are free at any BMW dealer, but the seller may never have had them done. Check each campaign number against the VIN before you buy.

  1. 26V422000BrakesJan 2026
  2. 24V104000Stability controlDec 2024
  3. 24V739000Stability controlFeb 2024
  4. 23V700000Electrical
  5. 23V885000Automatic emergency braking
  6. 24V135000Electrical
  7. 24V697000Stability control
  8. 24V714000Steering
  9. 25V395000Electrical
  10. 26V096000Electrical

Open a campaign number for NHTSA's full notice: what fails, the risk, and the fix.

Also looking at these instead of a i5?

Cars shoppers compare with the BMW i5, with their own 2024 checklists.